they both look good the mud gear lugs look taller but both look good for mud. i ride mostly trails to get to the mud but need something good in the mud and dirt trails and rock.... i have the older style dirt devils and they are great but there wearing down and they are more aggressive than the new dirt devils but i really dont like the way the new ones look. i like the mudgear more than the itp but which ones are heavier? and better for trail riding thanks again for everyones input