I would take the renegade. They are pretty bad-a$$!

 

You should check out the '10 Scrambler. Some pretty nice updates including the much needed styling update. It looks A LOT better in person than in any picture. I thought they were hideous in the pictures, but in person, they look pretty dam good.

 

The Scrambler's 4x4 is better but the Renegade beats it in a lot of other ways. I personally won't buy a Renegade because they cost to much. That's the bottom line for me. I'd get the Scrambler even though the handling's not as good.