i will only run steel cable. i was a logger for ten years or so, and saw firsthand what steel cable can take. on the other hand, synthetic cannot withstand a tiny nick while under tension. the synthetic does have the tensile strength if you never let it touch anything while pulling, but if it rubs a rock, or if you hook the cable around a tree and back into the rope, it will not be as strong. it it too sensitive for my use.

monty

 

Go with synthetic.........the number one reason is SAFETY.

It has virtually no recoil should it break..........unlike steel, which can whip around like a big "weed eater" and weed-eat your limbs.

It is stronger than steel per diameter. It's easier to handle.......and spool.
It's much lighter.
It doesn't "kink".
It won't leave metal splinters in your hand.

Other than that, I can't think of a reason to go with synthetic..............

 

"It won't leave metal splinters in your hand."

Not to mention - one of those frayed wires can cut your finger like a razor. NEVER handle winch cable without heavy gloves. And - if recovering with a cable, you're supposed to lay something with some weight on the center of the cable - in case it breaks, so it doesn't come back at you.

I agree with the pro-winch rope guys. Much safer.
I haven't experienced pulling my rope over an abrasive surface, but I did see frayed wires on my cable after one use, and it was an easy pull. The first thing I did when I got home is order the Amsteel winch rope.

I have no regrets.

The other thing is to not use your winch for "dragging" your buddy out of the mud. They weren't made for that. Either use the winch to pull the vehicle out as intended, or use a recovery strap. In other words, you shouldn't be backing up if you're getting your buddy un-stuck.

I personally use a recovery strap over the winch when it'll work.