New Generation "Quiet" Pipes
#22
New Generation "Quiet" Pipes
Originally posted by: garyc660R
True true. What happenned too the LRD quiet muffler that was not supposed too loose power? I remember someone talking about it.
Gary
Originally posted by: ShadyRascal
the first one with a quiet 4 stroke pipe that works is gonna be rich.
the first one with a quiet 4 stroke pipe that works is gonna be rich.
Gary
#23
New Generation "Quiet" Pipes
So now things are getting interesting. How to let air move, presure, yet reduce amplitude.
As note previously, sound absorbing material, baffling, and restriction (as in end caps) are
the traditional methods. Doesn't wave canceling not only involve reflecting the wave back
to the source, but reflecting back the presure as well?
It's been way too long since I took my physics courses, but it seems like a new approach
to an old problem is needed. Anyway, I agree that if the industry doesn't solve the problem
first, the government will, and they never do anything simple or straight forward!
That's the biggest reason I sold my 2-strokes (actually I still have my dirt bike) and took
to the plunge into the newer 4-strokes. Might as well do it for my reasons before the
government makes me do it for theirs.
As note previously, sound absorbing material, baffling, and restriction (as in end caps) are
the traditional methods. Doesn't wave canceling not only involve reflecting the wave back
to the source, but reflecting back the presure as well?
It's been way too long since I took my physics courses, but it seems like a new approach
to an old problem is needed. Anyway, I agree that if the industry doesn't solve the problem
first, the government will, and they never do anything simple or straight forward!
That's the biggest reason I sold my 2-strokes (actually I still have my dirt bike) and took
to the plunge into the newer 4-strokes. Might as well do it for my reasons before the
government makes me do it for theirs.
#24
New Generation "Quiet" Pipes
There is probably something to do with the pressure pulse being reflected back as well, which is undesireable. But like a helicopter you hear coming, it's just air pulses not engine noise, so the "thumper" air pulses of the 4 stroke need to be cancelled. But I still believe there is a way that some computer nerd could figure out to "break" the sound wave as it moves through a canister without the somewhat archaic notion of just making the exit hole smaller.
I can see some guy with sound waves printed on his computer screen and an advanced cad system playing theory games with this. How about some college kid making his thesis on this and getting rich off it?
I'm way too stupid, I'm just a dumb lumber salesman. [img]i/expressions/face-icon-small-cool.gif[/img]
I can see some guy with sound waves printed on his computer screen and an advanced cad system playing theory games with this. How about some college kid making his thesis on this and getting rich off it?
I'm way too stupid, I'm just a dumb lumber salesman. [img]i/expressions/face-icon-small-cool.gif[/img]
#25
New Generation "Quiet" Pipes
The yoshi pipe IS loud, and i didnt think it gave the Z i rode much more performance. I havent ridden a stock Z, but compared to my 450r (even stock), it didnt seem to give it much performance at all, but it could have, and i may just be too used to the 450r...
#26
New Generation "Quiet" Pipes
Riddle me this, Batman -
A single cylinder in a corvette engine has around the same displacement, compression and power output as a slightly modified Raptor engine. With both engines at full throttle at 5000rpm, why is a piped Raptor engine, at 1/8 the size of the Vette engine, MUCH louder?
There would be a lot more air flowing through the Vette exhaust system, so it can't just be airflow that makes an engine loud.
Also, my '71 Camaro has a v8 that is louder than both of the above, even though each cylinder is making less power than either the Vette or the Raptor.
I think a huge part of the sound equasion comes from the cam overlap and duration. Without changing anything else, put a "big" cam in a small block and put a "small" cam in the same engine and it will be much louder with the "big" cam. Once quad engines start making use of EFI, we will be able to run smaller, quieter cams with free flowing exhausts and make as much power as we do now.
My suggesion - don't try to make ATVs quieter by changing the exhaust, make them quieter by switching to EFI and smaller cams with less overlap and duration.
Just a thought. Does it sound reasonable?
RR1
A single cylinder in a corvette engine has around the same displacement, compression and power output as a slightly modified Raptor engine. With both engines at full throttle at 5000rpm, why is a piped Raptor engine, at 1/8 the size of the Vette engine, MUCH louder?
There would be a lot more air flowing through the Vette exhaust system, so it can't just be airflow that makes an engine loud.
Also, my '71 Camaro has a v8 that is louder than both of the above, even though each cylinder is making less power than either the Vette or the Raptor.
I think a huge part of the sound equasion comes from the cam overlap and duration. Without changing anything else, put a "big" cam in a small block and put a "small" cam in the same engine and it will be much louder with the "big" cam. Once quad engines start making use of EFI, we will be able to run smaller, quieter cams with free flowing exhausts and make as much power as we do now.
My suggesion - don't try to make ATVs quieter by changing the exhaust, make them quieter by switching to EFI and smaller cams with less overlap and duration.
Just a thought. Does it sound reasonable?
RR1
#27
New Generation "Quiet" Pipes
Originally posted by: Bopeep
So all this makes sense (and doesn't). I agree that a free flowing exhaust, regardless of
it's sound (db) rating needs rejetting to increase the intake of the system. However, that
said, the new dual exhaust from Pro-Circuit for the KFX 700 claims you don't have to do
anything but bolt it on.
I've always like Yoshi and White Brothers, that's why I'm so interested in the E2. I'll be really
interested to hear from kawip650 once he has some time on his new pipe. I finally did find some
sites, all motocross, dealing with the FMF Q, and the results are mixed. However, everyone
rejetted for this pipe! The consensus seems that it helped low to mid-range, but hurt the top-end.
I would just like to stay within that magic 96 - 98db range. It's not only easier on my ears, but
everyone elses as well!
So all this makes sense (and doesn't). I agree that a free flowing exhaust, regardless of
it's sound (db) rating needs rejetting to increase the intake of the system. However, that
said, the new dual exhaust from Pro-Circuit for the KFX 700 claims you don't have to do
anything but bolt it on.
I've always like Yoshi and White Brothers, that's why I'm so interested in the E2. I'll be really
interested to hear from kawip650 once he has some time on his new pipe. I finally did find some
sites, all motocross, dealing with the FMF Q, and the results are mixed. However, everyone
rejetted for this pipe! The consensus seems that it helped low to mid-range, but hurt the top-end.
I would just like to stay within that magic 96 - 98db range. It's not only easier on my ears, but
everyone elses as well!
I put the FMF Q pipe on my girlfriends yfz 450 i got her and jetted it 168 w/ a k&n. With the inner end peice in its not that loud at all and it helped it out. the triple combo works great together. but i took the inner "pea shooter" out and it gave it a healthy sounding growl..little less back pressure as well. Its definitely louder w/o it in ..but its a good pipe for the money
#28
#29
New Generation "Quiet" Pipes
Originally posted by: RaptorRacer1
Riddle me this, Batman -
A single cylinder in a corvette engine has around the same displacement, compression and power output as a slightly modified Raptor engine. With both engines at full throttle at 5000rpm, why is a piped Raptor engine, at 1/8 the size of the Vette engine, MUCH louder?
There would be a lot more air flowing through the Vette exhaust system, so it can't just be airflow that makes an engine loud.
Also, my '71 Camaro has a v8 that is louder than both of the above, even though each cylinder is making less power than either the Vette or the Raptor.
I think a huge part of the sound equasion comes from the cam overlap and duration. Without changing anything else, put a "big" cam in a small block and put a "small" cam in the same engine and it will be much louder with the "big" cam. Once quad engines start making use of EFI, we will be able to run smaller, quieter cams with free flowing exhausts and make as much power as we do now.
My suggesion - don't try to make ATVs quieter by changing the exhaust, make them quieter by switvhing to EFI and smaller cams with less overlap and duration.
Just a thought. Does it sound reasonable?
RR1
Riddle me this, Batman -
A single cylinder in a corvette engine has around the same displacement, compression and power output as a slightly modified Raptor engine. With both engines at full throttle at 5000rpm, why is a piped Raptor engine, at 1/8 the size of the Vette engine, MUCH louder?
There would be a lot more air flowing through the Vette exhaust system, so it can't just be airflow that makes an engine loud.
Also, my '71 Camaro has a v8 that is louder than both of the above, even though each cylinder is making less power than either the Vette or the Raptor.
I think a huge part of the sound equasion comes from the cam overlap and duration. Without changing anything else, put a "big" cam in a small block and put a "small" cam in the same engine and it will be much louder with the "big" cam. Once quad engines start making use of EFI, we will be able to run smaller, quieter cams with free flowing exhausts and make as much power as we do now.
My suggesion - don't try to make ATVs quieter by changing the exhaust, make them quieter by switvhing to EFI and smaller cams with less overlap and duration.
Just a thought. Does it sound reasonable?
RR1
Thinking out loud here, the Raptor blows a ton of air out the exhaust compared to the car. Short pipe in comparison as well as the other factors listed above, that aside I wonder what the actual cylinder pressure in the Raptor is compared to the car? I would surmise the Raptor cam has small amounts of overlap to build higher pressures. But your are very correct in my opinion that the EFI system "tames down" these cams and probably would result in some sound improvement.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
mrtidy
Polaris Ask an Expert! In fond memory of Old Polaris Tech.
9
02-03-2016 05:00 PM
greg86hd
Polaris Ask an Expert! In fond memory of Old Polaris Tech.
1
09-16-2015 12:32 AM
Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)