CBS Evening News
#21
The Empty Noggin Fairy??
on the serious side...You really gotta go get yourself a helmet. Not only for your own well being but to show the young kids that it is a must.
Please protect your empty "NOGGIN".
#22
Does anyone have a translator I can borrow?
I never blamed the ATV industry for anything. I challanged them to build a teen size quad that meets the legal limitations. (and I'm 225 and have ridden the 90 in places some of you wouldn't go)
No - the disporportionate injury rate is based on the number of accidents per number of ATV's nationally - not just in Minnesota. That is the CPSC agenda. If sales increase 50 percent one would expect a 50 percent increase in accidents. But this is not the case - its more like 100% increase. Thats whats drawing the CPSC's attention.
The example of Snowmobile to ATV accident rate was obtained from the Minnesota DNR made on KARE11 TV aired this last Sunday. It is only one if the examples that points to un-supervised use of motorsports equipment. Snowmobiles are not popular with smaller operators as it takes a good effort to horse one backwards or un-stick a stuck sled. Generally speaking, unaccompanied by a adult and under age 15 operators are rare. Therego the lower accident rates even with the same number of machines in use. Maybe a example that requres more explaining then what I should attempt here.
I think we agree on the parental responsibility but we may dissagree on quad size. But I beleive my posting is in line with the below statements from Russ Ehnes sighting the use of adult-sized quads being used by children.
The National Off-Highway Vehicle Conservation Council (NOHVCC), met with the federal Consumer Products Safety Commission (CPSC) panel June 5 for a hearing investigating ATV safety issues.
NOHVCC Executive Director Russ Ehnes spoke at the hearing and reported, "What the commission saw was that the overwhelming majority ATV-related injury that occurs in this country is because the rider was breaking at least one of the major safety rules set forth by the manufacturers of the vehicles. We saw numerous statistics regarding riders not wearing a helmet, riding double, riding on paved roads with automobile traffic, and alcohol use. As far as children being hurt, it was found that it was almost entirely occurring with their use of adult-sized ATVs rather than the smaller machines built for youth-sized riders."
Prior to the hearing, the commission stated that it was "concerned about the dramatic increase in ATV-related injuries and the continued increase in ATV-related deaths,
Nationally, the Commission has reports of 5,239 people who died on ATV's during period between 1982 and 2002
The Consumer Federation of America and other groups petitioned the Commission in September 2002 to ban adult-size, four-wheel ATVs sold for the use of children under the age of 16.
In response to the numerious postings that encourage ATV's for youth that do not meet the age guidelines I have tried to provide factual information so that we hear all sides of the issue allowing for informed decisions to be made. There is always the exceptional performer that makes one want to consider a larger or faster machine - but do it legally. My youngest daughter flys better than most private pilots - but she has to wait to turn 16 for her first solo flight. I have no fatality reports of children dying from severe "want".
As a DNR ATV Safety Instructor my job is to test youth to see if they meet the knowledge, skill and ability requirements so that they can ride larger than 90 cc quads once they turn 12 years old. We try to get them started off right and safely. Telling anyone to dissregard the laws and requlations would make us hipocrates and undermine respect for what it is we are trying to accomplish - safe legal youth operation of ATV's that fit them.</FONT>
#23
I can't believe I am saying this but everything you just posted I agree with! One thing that struck me though, was the 5,239 of people who have died, and that was in 20 years!! Although any loss of life it tragic, that number compared to other things in TINY!
I also want to know, and I have not been able to find this info but what is the number of those without proper safety gear? Also, how many were adults and how many children?
Nobody has disagreed with you about safety issues or children riding adult quads, we just don't want to have our sport legislated away!
Maybe instead of banning children on quads we should have manditory helmet laws for quads,maybe chest protectors, gloves, and goggles should be required? That will not happen because it is not the agenda of the groups pushing these issues to make kids safer it is to BAN ALL OF THEM!!!!
Chris
I also want to know, and I have not been able to find this info but what is the number of those without proper safety gear? Also, how many were adults and how many children?
Nobody has disagreed with you about safety issues or children riding adult quads, we just don't want to have our sport legislated away!
Maybe instead of banning children on quads we should have manditory helmet laws for quads,maybe chest protectors, gloves, and goggles should be required? That will not happen because it is not the agenda of the groups pushing these issues to make kids safer it is to BAN ALL OF THEM!!!!
Chris
#24
I agree with you part of the way.. but... I'd like to point out that the Raptor 80 is a kid sized machine... and according to the guidelines, my 9 year old, who is over 5 ft tall, and weighs in at over a hundred pounds can't ride it and meet their requirements. Heck, he is too big for it now...by the time he gets to 12, he will be larger than his 28 year old sister. A 50cc machine is just too underpowered to allow him to safely ride around on anything other than a flat surface. Put him on a trail with hills or in dunes etc, and he stands a good chance of getting in way over his head. At least with the 80, it has enough power to pull his weight.. but even it struggles in some situations.
The point that really frosted my cookies over this deal, is the safety council's refusal to allow him to attend the safety course.. and I am supposed to put him on a totally underpowered machine just to meet their requirements. That WOULD put him in a dangerous situation, and as a caring parent, I refuse to do that.
Conversly, I don't advocate letting him ride a full sized quad either... I don't feel he is mentally equiped to make the kind of decisions that come with the increased speed etc. He is just too young for it... All kids his age, regardless of size are TOO YOUNG for bigger machines.
What's a person to do?
The point that really frosted my cookies over this deal, is the safety council's refusal to allow him to attend the safety course.. and I am supposed to put him on a totally underpowered machine just to meet their requirements. That WOULD put him in a dangerous situation, and as a caring parent, I refuse to do that.
Conversly, I don't advocate letting him ride a full sized quad either... I don't feel he is mentally equiped to make the kind of decisions that come with the increased speed etc. He is just too young for it... All kids his age, regardless of size are TOO YOUNG for bigger machines.
What's a person to do?
#25
Originally posted by: Bubba297
My exact feelings on the entire matter! I couldn't have said it better myself.
Originally posted by: Fishez3WhoDatInDaMud,Here's the deal and I'm going to assume I'm not the only one that feels this way. Why is the ATV industry to blame? The media(People magazine and now CBS) are running stories with an obvious agenda. The stories are always the same, "Little Billy was just doing what he loved, riding his dad's (insert 700 lbs adult quad here) around the farm, around the track, around the neighborhood, or down the street. We had no idea something like this could ever happen. We would have never let him ride if we had known the outcome." Here is where you can help me. How is the ATV industry to blame? Rules and guidelines are already in place. The only person to blame for a tradgedy like the one above is the parents themselves! When a child is killed on an adult quad, the parent's should be prosecuted. When a child is hurt on any quad, while riding without proper protective gear, the parent's should be prosecuted.If my 13 year old decides to take my car for a joyride, has a wreck and is killed,,,should I(or others) blame Ford Motor Company?If my 13 year old unlocks my gun cabinet, takes out a shotgun and kills himself,,,should I(or others) blame Remington?If my 13 year old stabs somebody, should I(or others) blame Case or Buck knives?If my 10 year old is allowed to ride my 600 lbs. quad and is killed, should I(or others) blame Honda?The answers are not no, but h*ll no! It is very sad that in today's society, we are always looking to blame someone other than ourselves. As tragic as the accidents are that are being reported, it is even more tragic that the parents(and others) are trying to pass the buck for their own failed attempt at parenting. It's that simple, that cut and dry.With that being said, you stated that there have been disproportionate increases of ATV injuries in your state. Don't give us that goverment speak crap, give us real figures. 1. How many of those accidents were attributed to children riding adult quads? 2. How many were attributed to not wearing a helmet? 3. How many happened on public roads? If you take the above three out of the equation, do we have a story at all? I'd bet not.The bottom line is that the ATV industry is receiving an uncalled for black-eye from leftist media outlets and people who have failed at their jobs of parenting. Not some, but all the blame should fall squarely on the shoulders of the people who allow their children to ride adult sized quads, without protective gear, and unsupervised. Additional federal regulations are not the answer. Hold the people responsible for these tragadies, the parents, and prosecute them to the fullest extent of the law. This entire debate should be about protecting our children. Additional federal laws CAN NOT do that! I agree with some of the CPSC guidelines, others I do not. Children shouldn't be limited to a certain "class" based upon age alone. All 13 year olds are not alike. Some have been riding quads all their lives, others are first timers. You can't treat them all the same, based strictly on age.In a perfect world, I'd like to see all ATV dealers have to conduct an on-site "drivers test". Scores would be issued for how they "fit" the quad, as well as driving ability. The total score would determine if they were better suited for a 50cc, 90cc, 150cc quad.I hope this post doesn't come across as cold-hearted. As a parent of two, I can't fathom losing one of my children. However, if one of the above scenarios occured, I'd look squarely in the mirror when looking for someone to blame.I for one appreciate your contributions here, although I don't agree with a lot of them.Fish
Gary
#26
Originally posted by: Trx440
You fall off your quad, get your empty noggin smashed and go to the hospital where you ring up a $250,000 bill. You pay the portion that your insurance doesn't [under $10,000??]. Who pays the rest?? The Empty Noggin Fairy?? Everyone else does, that's who. You can't afford to ride without a helmet, so do US a favor and get a helmet or sign a waiver that states whenyou run out of money, pull the plug, since you take FULL responsibility for your empty headed actions.
Originally posted by: BobmanP.S. I don't wear a helmet....but I accept all responsibilities for any damages sustained to my empty noggin.
Gary
#27
There is another segment tonight. They are supposed to show dealers selling oversized quads to parents for their younger kids and more stupid parents letting kids do even more stupid things.
This CBS show is a real kick in the ***** to the sport!!!
CBS needs to interview and run a segment on the responsible parents that supervise and provide the proper training to ensure the kids safety.
This CBS show is a real kick in the ***** to the sport!!!
CBS needs to interview and run a segment on the responsible parents that supervise and provide the proper training to ensure the kids safety.
#28
Originally posted by: csamayfield55
Nobody has disagreed with you about safety issues or children riding adult quads, we just don't want to have our sport legislated away! Maybe instead of banning children on quads we should have manditory helmet laws for quads,maybe chest protectors, gloves, and goggles should be required?
Nobody has disagreed with you about safety issues or children riding adult quads, we just don't want to have our sport legislated away! Maybe instead of banning children on quads we should have manditory helmet laws for quads,maybe chest protectors, gloves, and goggles should be required?
I disagree. A teenager can handle an adult quad. Perfect size for a blaster.
All the laws and safety equipment in the world won't prevent chilldren from making bad decisions. Close supervision by a responsible adult is the only way to reduce accidents. No parent or guardian would let a child attempt something that the parent is not 100% sure they can handle. We love our kids too much to risk it. BUT, we can only stop them if we are present. Problem is that bad parents turn their kids loose and have no idea the risks they are taking.
#29
It would seem to me the manufacturers need to increase the physical size of smaller ATVs somewhat. Not a big quad but just a super sized mini with a little bit extra power but in the same motor. That way everyone is happy, bigger kids will not be to big for the quad anymore. There would be enough power to not get into trouble from not having enough power. The weight of the quad can be kept down very easy. The manufacturers should build these quads.
I tried to find 60 minutes last night but I couldn't see it on my dish, I'm going to look for it tonight too.
I tried to find 60 minutes last night but I couldn't see it on my dish, I'm going to look for it tonight too.


