I'm looking to upgrade from the stock 489's on my 05' Scrambler 4x4. Knowing that talking tires is like talking religion and politics....I think I've narrowed it down to three options, Mudlite XTR's, Holeshot XCRs, or 589's. Can any fellow Scrambler 4x4 riders provide testament on these three tires to help me make my decision...?

I do mostly North Central trail riding (WI, MI, MN) and whatever mud I encounter along the way (no hardcore mudding...yet)

p.s. I plan to keep the stock rims...rubber only.

 

I would add Alltracks to that list, too. I haven't had them on my scrammy...yet...but had them on my quad before (2x4) and they were a great tire.

 

I personally havent seen any tire that is as ALL AROUND good as the 489s

 

I personally havent seen any tire that is as ALL AROUND good as the 489s

 

guy i used to live by had the 489s and he liked them. his scrammy rode nice too.