I got a primary clutch puller from HPD. It doesn't seem to fit my clutch. It gets tight right off and doesn't match the threads. A Polaris puller got my clutch off only a few days ago so I know the clutch is fine. Did they send me the wrong one or what?

 

I'd say give them a call. Do the threads on the end look damaged? Possibly during shipping...just an idea. They'll make it good.